The Killing Fields

JS90873954So yesterday the registration deadline for the third round of Champions League qualifiers came and went without our club bothering to make a signing. Just how big a problem is that?

Well, in the first leg of the last round we played Efe Ambrose at central defence, with the predictable results. Such was the magnitude of that disaster – our worst result in our history – that we dropped him entirely from the second leg and played three at the back with our young full-back Keiran Tierney deputising for the night as a centre back instead.

Brendan Rodgers knows we have problems in that area. He has asked the board repeatedly, publicly and privately, for the signings he needs. One of the names he and his assistant have trailed over the weeks has been Shane Duffy. Today we discovered that the club is yet to make a formal bid for the Blackburn Rovers defender.

It makes you wonder how hard people are trying.

This is a perilous place for our club to be. Brendan Rodgers is the huge managerial appointment the Celtic supporters wanted. His is the name we craved. But we didn’t get this guy off the slag-heap. He wasn’t waiting around for our call, and willing to go anywhere. The chances are very good that if this guy hadn’t been appointed at Celtic Park that he would have been unveiled as the England boss this very week. Forget Allardyce and others; England’s FA would have passed over these second raters for Brendan in an instant. That’s how good a boss we’re talking about.

There’s a caricature of Brendan in some parts of the English media, that he’s vain and ego-driven. They point to frivolous stuff like his having his teeth done and hair fixed and the diets he went on. They point to his good looking young fiancé, who he proposed to just after formalising his divorce from his ex. In short, they think he’s a bit of a Jack the Lad.

As far as Celtic fans are concerned, all of it is nonsense because it has nothing to do with his ability as a boss.

Yet there’s undoubtedly truth to a lot of it anyway, and that does give us some insight which might be important.

Brendan has a very healthy self-regard.

He likes the limelight and he likes to be seen to be doing well.

This is not a negative. This is a guy who won’t settle for second place, or for failure. That’s why we appointed him.

It’s also why we will struggle to hang onto him if the board of directors continues to fail him when it matters.

There’s a moment at the start of the fantastic 1997 movie Twin Town where two corrupt cops are having a discussion about a piece of corporate art, etched into the stonework outside Swansea Train Station.

It reads “Ambition Is Critical.”

As they discuss the meaning, the older of the two men claims that it’s a response to an alleged Dylan Thomas quote, that Swansea is “the graveyard of ambition.”

A local poet wrote the three word answer to that. He worked for the council.

They adopted it as the town’s moto.

I always laugh at that scene, especially Dougray Scott and his assertion that it’s a dreadful slogan. His own three word take on Swansea a “Pretty Shitty City” at least rhymes.

He is scornful of the notion that anything, far less ambition, can thrive in such a place.

Ambition is critical though, and if someone had inscribed those words on the stairs at Celtic Park I think most of us would get the point at once. What I’m not sure of is that everyone who stepped over them on the way into work in the morning would.

Ironically enough, Brendan made his name in Swansea and it wasn’t the graveyard of his ambitions at all.

It was the proving ground for them. It was his performance there that took him to Anfield, and made him a contender. It was the place where he showed the world what he could do, where he’d have first come to the attention of Celtic.

He arrives at our club via a sojourn at Liverpool, where things went spectacularly right and then horribly wrong.

Is he here to rebuild his reputation?

No, I wouldn’t go that far. He says Celtic is a natural fit for him, and I agree. We are still a massive club, with huge pull for the right man, someone who “gets it”, someone who understands.

I was furious last week when, in the aftermath of the Red Imps result, Brendan Rodgers offered his glib, unconcerned response to the club’s stunning defeat. The result was easily the worst over 90 minutes in our history; some have argued that, but none has been able to find another occasion where we lost a competitive game to such a side.

There are simply no comparisons that come even close.

In my heart of hearts I know Brendan was angered by that result, and that his comments in public hid a deep frustration in private. He knows how that result makes our club, and him, look in the eyes of the world.

He’s not the kind of man to take that lightly.

He’ll know something else; he’ll know that good managers have come to Scotland before and died on their arses.

Some say Scottish football is the graveyard of ambition; it’s not.

These are the killing fields.

It’s not widely talked about, but Scottish football hasn’t just stalled careers. It has wrecked them. For such a small place, such a little corner of the footballing universe, this place has a helluva reputation for ruining folk, and Glasgow in particular.

Look back over the recent history of football in this city.

There are a parade of names who have come here, and then gone bust.

At Celtic, John Barnes career was obliterated before it had properly begun. He didn’t manage at another club for nine years, when he went to Tranmere, who sacked him after just eleven games.

Kenny Dalglish, who was a hero in English football, especially at Liverpool and Blackburn, wilted under the pressure of trying to steer the team after Barnes was fired. He won a League Cup but it was nowhere near enough. The Celtic board’s decision not to give him a permanent crack at the job was vindicated when they appointed Martin O’Neill instead.

It would be almost a decade before Dalglish returned to management, for a brief spell as caretaker boss at Anfield.

On its own, success in Scotland doesn’t guarantee the kind of advancement one might expect either, but failure here, even perceived failure, can undo good work that might otherwise count in your favour.

Martin O’Neill had a right to think he would have been a contender at any top club in England when he got Celtic to the UEFA Cup Final in Seville, but when he left the club the league title resided at Ibrox and that must have been a bad sign for some down south.

He ended up at Villa, then at Sunderland, instead of one of the clubs he craved.

The same could be said of Gordon Strachan and Neil Lennon, good men both, one of whom got us out of two Champions League groups in a row and the other who masterminded a win against Barcelona. Gordon left Celtic having lost a league title. Neil left after a Champions League group stage car-crash, but one no-one could blame him for. Nevertheless, only Bolton offered him a job.

At Ibrox, the same pattern emerges.

Alex McLeish became Scotland manager after leaving there but his managerial career petered out with moves to Birmingham, Villa, Forest and finally a move abroad, where he took over at Genk. He was in Egypt managing a club at the turn of this year, but they sacked him after just a few months in the job.

Even the big names to take over there encountered disaster.

Dick Advocaat left Ibrox to take on the Dutch national team, and ended up at Zenit St Petersburg with all their money, yet it could be argued that his career ran onto the rocks in this city when Rangers dispensed with his services after Martin O’Neill proved he had the mastery as Celtic stormed to two titles on the bounce.

Advocaat arrived at Ibrox with a huge reputation. He could have ended up anywhere, at a top European club, but this country exposed his limitations with a brutality that must have taken him by surprise.

The same thing happened to Paul LeGuen and in even less time; his was a glittering CV which less than a year here absolutely shredded. He was never to recover the ground he lost in that 12 months. He went to Paris St Germain from Ibrox, before money transformed that club completely. They were 17th on the day he was appointed; no other club in France would touch him.

What I’m trying to say here is that no-one should be under the misconception that Scottish football is some kind of soft option or doss. None of the guys named above left on a high, save maybe for Lenny. Even Gordon and Martin left after surrendering league titles.

Ronny Deila is an exceptional case because he actually lost his job despite winning the title.

But none of these guys was head-hunted by a bigger team.

None went on to “better things”.

Failure here is like a near-death experience and these are the guys (Barnes excepted) who got out without being absolutely humiliated.

Tony Mowbray had his reputation as a title winning boss at West Brom to fall back on, but his time at Celtic Park had made him toxic to most clubs in England; ironically, he replaced Gordon Strachan at Middlesbrough shortly after Celtic let him go.

Which is to say nothing for Ally McCoist, whose failures at Sevco were about as colossal as one could ever hope to see.

I predicted in 2012 that he would never manage a top flight team again and I see nothing at all to suggest I was mistaken then or now. Indeed, he may never manage in football again; that wouldn’t surprise me at all.

Brendan Rodgers doesn’t see Celtic as a “stepping stone” but that doesn’t mean he’d be willing leave our club with his reputation in the toilet. The current squad isn’t good enough; he knows it and the more dreadful events of last season have left us in no doubt about it. If we needed further evidence of it we got it last week. This is a side that more and more resembles one needing radical surgery. Sticking plaster solutions just aren’t going to cut it and we’ve got big problems ahead unless we refresh it with some new blood.

If Brendan Rodgers thinks he needs certain players to take the Celtic team forward I know for sure that he will fight for them; he has to. Never before in our history has second place been worth less to us, never in our history has it been so absolutely unacceptable, and if that’s the case for the fans it’ll be even more so for a manager who does think a lot of himself and who might still fancy managing at the highest level if and when he leaves Celtic Park.

Hell will be paid for failure, and not just in the manager’s office, but it’s the manager who will pay the highest price and it’s to be wondered if his career would recover from it. His days of managing top clubs would certainly be at an end.

Brendan Rodgers won’t accept that.

He knows, furthermore, that only a quantifiable success in Europe will keep his career from ending as those others did.

That quest was dealt a shocking blow last week.

With Astana next up, there clear potential for something just as bad.

Brendan Rodgers will not accept that.

He won’t tolerate having his hands tied.

This guy has a deep affinity for Celtic, but I absolutely believe he would be willing to walk away and scorch the Earth behind him if he thought his own reputation was being damaged by working here with no backing. He won’t do it right away, of course, but he’ll already be angry and concerned and if, in Astana next week, Champions League horror follows on top of last week’s Champions League horror, when all the signs were there, when the need for at least one signing who could play in the team was acture, I think he’d have valid concerns and be harbouring serious doubts about the commitment of those above him to make good on their own “ambition.”

This is a man who will not quietly fall on the killing fields.

This site needs your support. If you are able to, and you want to help real Scottish football journalism, and not the sort you get in the tabloids, you can make a donation by clicking the link below.


James Forrest

James Forrest is a writer and blogger from Glasgow, and the author of two books, Fragments and Believers, which are available on Amazon.

11 thoughts on “The Killing Fields

  • 22 July, 2016 at 5:00 pm

    Did we lose to Red Imps? Surely it would be more accurate to say that we were trailing 1-0 at the halfway stage in the tie. The worst result in our history is a glib assertion; have you forgotten losing to Arthurlie in the Scottish Cup?

  • 22 July, 2016 at 5:05 pm

    James, my dear fellow tim. There is no evidence that Brendan Rodgers or Celtic have been chasing Shane Duffy. Your argument is based on speculation from SMSM. Why are you so obsessed by signings. Sevco have signed 9. None will get into a celtic team. BR or assistant CD have said repeatedly that they are after quality and that is not easy to get. I’m sure in fullness of time BR will get the signings we need. Stop shouting from the rooftop and don’t let yourself to be manipulated by Daily Radar.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 5:21 pm

    i agree with most of what you’ve written, BUT, i agree with rodgers saying the imps defeats wasn’t embarrassing. imagine the lift imps would get if he had said it, and imagine the press response if he had said it.
    he’d have done the imps managers team talk for him.
    and the smsm would have ripped into him for being disrespectful.
    dint think for one second that he hasn’t told the players in private that it was humiliating, and that they need to seriously have a look at themselves.

    when i checked the news this morning to see if we had signed anyone, i was thinking the same as you. i was concerned that we hadn’t even brought in a short term loan as cover for centre half. we have two injured, who with the right management, may be able to turn themselves around. i think jozo looked decent until his loss of form, which we now know was due to injury. if he can stay fit, he deserves a chance.
    have the board been trying to get signings, have they met obstacles because of the standard of player we are trying to approach? if we go out of the CL because we didnt pull out all the stops for a centre half, then there could be empty stands again.
    i for one, will not be buying europa league tickets (as i didnt last season), and i am amongst the 13 people who attend league cup games.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 5:28 pm

    tom campbell. we DID lose to red imps.
    after 90 minutes in gibraltar, celtic returned to glasgow trailing 1-0. that was a loss. we didnt lose the tie, but we lost a match. it was humiliating.
    im guessing the loss to arthurlie in the scottish cup was way before my time, but id also hazard a guess that the financial gap between celtic and red imps is bigger than it was between them and arthurlie back whenever that happend.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 5:29 pm

    jamsey. celtic havent announced that they havent made a bid for duffy. that came from his manager at blackburn, who doesnt want to lose him.
    not sure id believe him quite so quickly.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 5:49 pm

    Well I know I mentioned cup losses to Morton at home and Clyde away as potentially worse than Lincoln Red Imps, on basis the Imps do have many full time professionals in their squad unlike Morton and Clyde who were all part time players. Plus the two legged set up meant the defeat in Gibralter was awful but not critical. I’d even suggest drawing at home to Arbroath as being pretty grim. So while you are entitled to disagree, to say no one suggested a worse competitive result was wrong.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 6:40 pm

    You keep saying how ‘you know Brendan Rodgers will not accept that ‘ and ‘how he will fight’ for players or what he believes in. Do you know him personally? I presume you do because absolutely nothing in his managerial career suggest the character you are describing. He was not his own man at Liverpool, and this enabled him to divert some of the blame for the astronomical spending which still resulted in failure. He was under tight conditions at Swansea. Rodgers is an enigma. He has a huge reputation, huge salary yet has not really done much to deserve either. It is uncomfortable for Celtic supporters to accept this but this is already apparent, he is a Yes man. He is the investment and hsi ego is expected to make things better. He is an expensive Ronnie Deila. He is already reading Big Peter’s scripts. ‘It won’t be the fault of this club…’ utter shite. He has had two months to sign a replacement for Simunovic or is Brendan such a huge Celtic supporter that he didn’t realise this area is a problem. Simunovic has been injured since January. Now Blackburn are saying that no approach has ever been made for Duffy. Rodgers will do exactly as he is told and will read the scripts prepared for him by our leading Tories. Celtic supporters have been ripped off. Now the question is, is there any money? Or are there bigger problems? If Celtic go out of the CL in the next two weeks having only signed a teenager who has never played a top league game it will be chalked up as a huge failure. he whole club will be in a depression for months, in short, his time at Celtic will be short, I predict a year and possibly not very successful. What is happening at Celtic is a disgrace.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 6:42 pm

    Losng to Red Imps is the worst result in Celtic’s history. There is no doubt. I believe it will be all Rodgers will be remembered for.

  • 22 July, 2016 at 11:12 pm

    What’s the odds he’ll be gone by xmas?

  • 25 July, 2016 at 12:12 am

    The only consolation i take from the Imp game is the turnaround and that it was a game with a chance to reverse.
    Celtic had no excuses even if conditions were against them, in fitness levels,pitch or heat; Celtic should with their resources be prepared for whatever comes their way in serious games. Friendlies who cares but games that are required to advance in the future preparation is a must.

Leave a Reply

error: Content is protected !!